When it comes to sharing information, garnering awareness, and organizing campaigns there are few forms of media that can compete with the accessibility and reach of Internet-based "social networking" sites. For every "MySpace," "Twitter," and "LinkedIn," there are many dozens of smaller sites that are scraping and clawing for their own share of this burgeoning market.And then there's Facebook.
In only 6 years, Facebook has evolved from a quaint and entertaining novelty to a bona fide brand unto itself, now boasting over 500 million users worldwide. It's become a billion-dollar enterprise, enjoying a far-reaching and profound influence upon social networking, the Internet and upon popular culture itself.
Of course, as individuals and groups see the power and appeal of Facebook, it is understandable and expected that such a user-friendly service might be harnessed to further all sorts of objectives and causes. Such was the vision shared by supporters of Colombian revolutionary Ricardo Palmera when they created a Facebook page aimed at publicizing the rather unusual twists and turns of Palmera's battles in the American legal system.
The Facebook group "Free Ricardo Palmera!" was created by three members of The National Committee to Free Ricardo Palmera. In its relatively short existence on the web, the group's membership grew to nearly 700 members before Facebook administrators deleted the page on June 30, acting without any sort of advance notice or legitimate justification. Josh Sykes, one of the co-founders of the "Free Ricardo Palmera!" Facebook group explained the situation in an interview with Fight Back! News:
Facebook's reason was that it violated the 'terms of use' so they shut it down on June 30. They said that it was obscene, that it attacked people, or was hateful. Nothing could be further from the truth. They also threatened the administrators of the group with having their profiles disabled if we continued to "abuse" facebook features - which we never did.
(Read the full interview here)
(Read the full interview here)
On July 7, the personal Facebook account of Josh Sykes and those of the group's co-founders, Angela Denio and Tom Burke, were also locked by Facebook, ostensibly as a penalty for organizing support for Palmera. A groundswell of support for Sykes, Denio and Burke followed on the web and beyond. Under pressure from individual users and sympathetic organizations and media groups, Facebook eventually reinstated the accounts of Sykes and Denio while still attempting to justify the deletion of the Palmera group with vague and disingenuous terminology:
After reviewing your situation, we have determined that your group violated our Statement of Rights and Responsibilities. One of Facebook's main priorities is the comfort and safety of our users. We do not allow credible threats to harm others, support for violent organizations, or exceedingly graphic content. Your violation of Facebook's standards has resulted in the permanent loss of your group. We will not be able to reactivate this group for any reason. This decision is final.
The Palmera group remains a virtual "third rail" along with a number of other causes that are unwelcome on Facebook. In the weeks and months leading up to the sacking of the Palmera group, Facebook also disabled a group calling for a boycott of BP as well as a page condemning Israeli oppression of Palestinians. The glaring inconsistency in Facebook's allegedly egalitarian motivations lies in the fact that plenty of other Facebook pages – including those created by groups who openly espouse racism, fascism, misogyny and even murder – remain unchallenged and unmolested despite a flagrant disregard for Facebook's terms of use. Some might view this as simple irony in that Facebook purports to support free speech, information sharing and democracy around the world. The sad reality is that their actions with regard to the Palmera group and other causes are demonstrative of calculated and intentional censorship; In a word, we're talking about hypocrisy.
It's not necessarily a matter of expecting wealthy, propertied interests to uphold apparently elusive concepts like "free speech" because for progressives who see the inherent repression in bourgeois society, we must surely have reasonable expectations based on what we see and experience from day to day and from year to year. There was a time when people might have legitimately expected Facebook to stand for something radically different. These expectations are now little more than illusions. In retrospect, perhaps it's not so surprising that Facebook—a business entity that has effectively redefined the elite ranks of global mass media—has slowly become yet another arm of ruling elites and the military-industrial-media complex. Facebook has indeed descended into the bowels of the corporate sewer and, to quote Russian poet Alexander Pushkin, "If you live in the toilet, you get used to shit and the smell no longer bothers you."
Tom Burke, co-founder of the "Free Ricardo Palmera!" group on Facebook remains in social networking limbo as Facebook administrators ponder his virtual fate. Meanwhile, individuals and groups continue to struggle against censorship on Facebook, mounting campaigns to reinstate Burke's account while creating new pages to shed light on the struggle of Ricardo Palmera.
Read more about the situation through Fight Back! News here and watch an interview with Josh Sykes and Angela Denio on YouTube.
